25 Pumpkin Spice-Flavored Products You'll Want to Try — and 13 to Skip

Many people enjoy a pumpkin spice latte in a toast to autumn, and pumpkin pie is certainly a seasonal delight. And, just a few years back, those two things pretty much ran the fall pumpkin spectrum for most of us. Not so anymore — in fact, pumpkin has been added to a litany of snack foods, dog treats, and even self-care products like body wash, cologne, and lip balm. Read on for the pumpkin products we're psyched to try, and those we're going to take a pass on. 

Prices and availability are subject to change. Some items may be available only in-store or from third-party sellers on Amazon.

Related: 13 Things to Do With Pumpkin Guts After Carving

Kris Scott contributed to this story.

$11 from Walmart
Shop Now

Reviewers tend to be pretty pleased by the flavor and natural ingredients of this bar, so if you're looking for a pumpkin-spice something to fuel your weekend hiking or biking sessions, this one isn't a bad option. 

For more great shopping guides and food tips, please sign up for our free newsletters.

$20 from Macy's
Shop Now

"What's a shower without a little pumpkin?"... said no one, ever. But if lathering up with pumpkins sounds appealing, then philosophy's Pumpkin Icing Shower Gel may be your go-to autumn product. Bonus? The brand's 3-in-1 formulas are said to work equally well as shower gel, bubble bath, or shampoo.

Related: We Tried 7 Lotions for Dry Skin and This Is the Best

$4 from Target
Shop Now

The professional cereal reviewers (yes, that's a thing) at Cerealously were not enthused about this product, saying the spice balance was off, and the same was true with Junk Banter's take on it, so it goes into the skip category.  

Related: 25 Pumpkin-Flavored Products That Have Gone Too Far

$3 from Walmart
Shop Now

If opting for the scallion cream cheese instead of the classic schmear on your bagel is your idea of mixing it up, then Philadelphia Pumpkin Spice Cream Cheese Spread may just blow your mind. But it's apparently pretty popular, so who are we to judge?

Related: 25 Ways to Make Unpopular Fall Vegetables More Delicious

$17 from Amazon
Shop Now

You might have to take a moment to reach the classic pretzel taste if you bite into Creative Snack Co.'s limited-edition Pumpkin Spice Yogurt Pretzels. But for those who like their classic snacks with an autumn twist, this just might do the trick.

$3 from Target
Shop Now

Even Hostess is caught up in the craze, pushing limited-edition Pumpkin Spice Twinkies: the classic golden sponge cake with pumpkin spice creamy filling. According to one reviewer, however, the pumpkin spice flavor here is underwhelming. 

Related: Twinkies, Moon Pies, and Other Guilty Pleasures You Can Make at Home

$9 from Harry & David
Shop Now

Apple butter is a country favorite found in many regions. Pumpkin butter, not as much. But thanks to Harry & David, the blend of real pumpkin, pecans, sugar, and spices can be had anywhere, any time. Pass the English muffin.

$6 from Target
Shop Now

Cucina Antica Pasta Sauce in Tuscany Pumpkin is an all-natural, gluten-free option that pairs imported San Marzano Italian plum tomatoes with... yes, the p-word, again. We admit, it seems like it would taste weird, but reviews seem largely positive (although to be fair, people who don't like it really don't like it, so you've been warned). 

Related: Target, Walmart, Aldi: Which Cheap Pasta Sauce Is a Winner?

$2/ounce from Pipes and Cigars
Shop Now 

We're sure this probably smells good, but we just can't get behind smoking your pumpkin spice when you can eat it, so yeah ... no.

$4 from Walmart
Shop Now

Yes, even this dairy-centric breakfast staple has also become fair game. Chobani's version gets pretty positive reviews across the board, and it's a departure from many of the carb-heavy options on this list, so go for it. 

Related: 45 Comfort Foods for a Cozy Fall Meal

$26 from Drizly
Shop Now

If you're more into liqueurs, Bailey's is at the seasonal rescue with its Irish Cream Pumpkin Spice Liqueur. Apparently, it delivers on the pumpkin spice, and in a year when pumpkin spice lattes and cocktails are happening way more often at home than elsewhere, why not? 

Related: Best Cheap Beers for Fall: 10 Craft Brews to Toast the Season

$4 (.17 oz.) and up from Demeter
Shop Now

Demeter's Fragrance Library has quite a volume in its collection of "Simple, subtle, singular scents" — including Pumpkin Pie. The Pick-Me-Up Cologne Spray is said to feature pumpkin, sugar, cinnamon, a touch of ginger, and hint of cloves. We have a hard enough time eating all this pumpkin stuff, let alone dousing our bodies in it. Pass.

Related: 25 Creative Ways to Enjoy Apples This Season

$14 from Amazon
Shop Now

This sauce received largely positive reviews on Amazon, with many buyers noting that it can contribute to a pretty spot-on homemade pumpkin spice latte. If you like it and you're gonna drink a ton of the stuff, this four-pack is a better deal.

Related: How to Make Your Own Pumpkin Spice Latte: 10 Recipes to Try at Home

$3 from Walmart
Shop Now

If ever there was a brand that embraced the PS bandwagon, it's Pepperidge Farm. From what we can gather reading online reviews of this product, it's light on pumpkin flavor but still tastes pretty good.  

Unavailable for purchase in the U.S.

So, if you're the type of adventurous eater who likes to try all things pumpkin spice, you're out of luck with this one. It's only available in Canada, where it appears there are a lot of people willing to assault their taste buds with something we suspect can't possibly be any good. The maximum 1,000 people have already signed up to receive this abomination, creating a waitlist of culinary masochists. 

Related: 40 Foods That Americans are Missing Out On

$3 from Walmart
Shop Now

This is the only item on this entire list that we actually had in our cabinets, thanks to a 2019 tour of the Celestial Seasoning's factory near Boulder, Colorado. And we can indeed attest that, with a little honey and milk thrown in, this makes a delicious tea that evokes fall.

$10 from Kroger (only in Ohio, Kentucky, and Tennessee)
Shop Now

This product is brand new, only available in limited release, and it's tough to find reviews, so we're gonna go with our gut on this one. There are lots of great flavors that lend themselves well to hard seltzer — we just can't get on board with pumpkin being one of them.

Related: 19 Tasty Spiked Seltzers to Try

$18 from Amazon
Shop Now

Ninety percent of reviewers on Amazon give this product four or five stars and enthusiastically pepper their reviews with a no-holds-barred approach to exclamation remarks, so we gotta put this one the "try" category.

Related: We Tried 11 Hot Cocoa Mixes and This is the Best

$12 from Amazon
Shop Now

While these sounded pretty good to us, we can't ignore the reviews that note that they're either too sweet or tasteless, and even more numerous notes on how the cookies fall apart too easily and are mere crumbs by the time the package gets cracked open. It's gonna be a pumpkin pass on this one.

$2 from Walmart
Shop Now

Something that costs this little should probably not taste that great, but reviewers consistently note surprise and delight at the flavor of this mix.

Related: Over 50 Store-Brand Foods That Deliver Quality and Savings

$12 from Amazon
Shop Now

It's tough to see how a combination of peanut butter and pumpkin flavors can be a bad thing, but plenty of Amazon buyers seem to disagree. Although the product has largely good reviews on the site, those seem to be for the brand overall and not this particular flavor. One representative comment: "I hate it and I’m really sad that I hate it. I love PBfit. But PBfit Pumpkin Spice is BAD."

$3 from Walmart
Shop Now

These don't have the most stellar reviews on Walmart.com, which concerned us until we noted most of the reviews were for a different product. On Influenster and Pillsbury, the reviews are pretty stellar.

Related: Walmart's Chocolate Chip Cookies Beat Top Brands in Taste Test

$3 from Target
Shop Now

There is nothing below a four-star review from Target buyers on this product, so if you're the kind of person who's going to eat a Pop-Tart anyway, it seems like this flavor isn't likely to disappoint.

$13 from Amazon
Shop Now

Even if these weren't a ridiculous price on Amazon, we'd recommend you skip these. They have inconsistent reviews from food bloggers and Amazon buyers, noting a lack of flavor, a strange consistency, and a tendency for them to get all squished together.

Related: 50 Things to Pick Up at the Grocery Store This Fall

$4 from Renfro Foods
Shop Now

We didn't want to be on board with this, but limited reviews note that it's not nearly as weird as it sounds, and Mrs. Renfro's is pretty beloved for their salsa line, so ... try?

$3 from Walmart
Shop Now

Now here's a candy that knows how to pack in the pumpkin flavor, although — according to buyers — the flavor is more pumpkin pie than spice. Still, they get solid reviews from lots of folks, so we're sticking them squarely in the "try" category. 

Related: We Tried 15 Kinds of Chocolate and These Are the Best

$3 from Target
Shop Now

We really wanted to put these in the "try" category, but nearly a third of reviews on target give them one star, noting that the presence of pumpkin essence here is lacking, which is fairly unforgivable if you're gonna claim the "pumpkin spice" category.

$15 from Target
Shop Now

Do dogs care about pumpkin spice trends? No. Do buyers give these good reviews and say their dogs eat them? Yes. So, sure, why not?

Related: 16 Pet Subscription Boxes Your Pup Will Love

$14 from Amazon
Shop Now

Reviews can be mixed on this one, with some saying these taste overwhelmingly of nutmeg and others saying they're just right, but in a list of carb- and sugar-heavy treats, this bar is one of the healthier options, so it's probably worth a shot for that alone.

$12 from Amazon (2-pack)
Shop Now

Buyers tend to be happy with this product, and one reviewer from Taste of Home noted that she could taste the flavors of clove, nutmeg, and cinnamon and that these weren't overwhelmingly sweet. If you like a pumpkin spice breakfast option, these seem like they hit the mark.

$3 from Target
Shop Now

If you're looking for a pumpkin spice-inspired reason to eat what is basically cookies for breakfast, Belvita — according to multiple reviewers — delivers.

Related: A History of Dessert Posing as Cereal

$23 from Amazon
Shop Now

Between the price (basically $2 per cookie) and the inconsistent reviews, which included people receiving — ew — moldy cookies, we can't recommend these.

$3 from Target
Shop Now

One more product in the pumpkin spice breakfast realm, Nature's Path's frozen waffles get high points from buyers for their flavor and for being one of the few gluten-free options out there in this flavor genre.

Related: 25 Places to Find Amazing Waffles Across the Country

$11 from Amazon
Shop Now

Only about half of Amazon buyers liked these enough to give them five stars, and the reviews on a Nestle product page are even worse. There, reviewers claim the product has changed significantly from years past, claiming that the new formula causes greasiness and just doesn't taste as good.

Related: 25 Betty Crocker-Era Holiday Recipes That We Secretly Love

$9 from Amazon
Shop Now

If you're a Werther's fan anyway, these soft candies won't disappoint, but if you're looking for a punch of pumpkin spice, you won't find it here. Multiple reviewers note that the candy is light-to-the-point-of-nonexistent on that classic fall flavor.

Related: 20 Things You Didn't Know About Apples

$4 on Amazon
Shop Now

Blended with almond milk and coconut cream, this is supposed to be a better-for-you creamer, which made us wonder if it sacrificed on taste. Not so, say Amazon buyers — nearly 80% give it five-star reviews.

$4 from Walmart
Shop Now

If the description wasn't enough to convince you that this one is worth a try — Talenti's Pumpkin Pie Gelato contains pie crust pieces and a "rich brown sugar sauce" — then the reviews would. "So happy I found this!" wrote one. "Bring on the sweater weather with a pint of this!"

Related: Taste Test: Which Ice Cream Sandwich is the Best?

$10 from Amazon
Shop Now

If just reading everything that came before on this list made you feel like you've gained 10 pounds, then here's a pumpkin spice product that you won't have to work off in the gym. Buyers say it both smells great and does a fine job keeping lips moisturized.