The Best White Elephant Gifts at Costco, According to Superfans

$6 from Instacart, $5 at Costco

Forget 10 lords a-leaping. This Christmas, we're doing things Costco style, which means bringing 10 seasoned, spit-roasted birds to the white elephant party. If you're wild enough to go through with this, don't forget to refrigerate them. Cooked chicken shouldn't sit out for more than two hours.

Costco

Pendleton Sherpa Fleece Blanket

$27 from Costco.com

Costco superfans are wild about these fleece blankets, with numerous posts on Reddit praising the warm, soft, and pet-approved throws. In other words, we know this will be a hit white elephant gift.

Costco

$50 Costco Cash Card

$25 and up from Costco.com

While a $50 gift card might be a tad boring and uninspired, Redditors say that it will be a hit with white elephant players because A) it's flexible (like cash) and B) it allows non-members to shop at Costco.

Costco

Battery Daddy (Plus Batteries)

$18 from Instacart

Based on Costco shoppers fanaticism for the battery daddy — one shopper called it "brilliant" — we think this sophisticated storage system will be highly sought-after. It can hold up to 180 batteries and includes a battery tester. If you've got extra cash to spare and want to make this white elephant gift even more enticing, fill it with fresh batteries.

For more great gift guides and holiday shopping tips, please sign up for our free newsletters.

Costco

Life Comfort 10-Foot Wide Family Blanket

$35 from Costco.com

Both excessive and practical, this 10-foot wide family blanket is sure to be a coveted white elephant gag gift. Whether someone has to share a couch with blanket thieves or they just like to be cozy, ` definitely be fighting over this extra-large throw.

Costco

Brookstone Heated Throw Blanket

$37 from Costco.com

As we enter the coldest months of the year, who wouldn't want a plush heated blanket? That's the thought that'll be running through participants' heads as they plan their cutthroat strategy to snag this gift.

Costco

Steaks

$23 and up from Costco.com

While steak is, in theory, odd enough to be a fun white elephant gift, it might fall flat if there are vegetarians and vegans in your group. That said, one Redditor points out that, "Most people want consumables instead of stuff."

Costco

Pyrex Snapware

$30 from Instacart

Whether you're a meal-prepper, home chef, parent, or all of the above, Pyrex snapware is universally loved and will inspire envy in white elephant participants. This set includes nine containers and lids.

Costco

Kirkland French Vodka

$27 from Instacart

Costco's Kirkland French vodka is undoubtedly the wholesaler's most well-respected and well-known spirit that — assuming everyone is of age — is bound to change hands multiple times.

Costco

Pou-Pourri Toilet Spray

$25 from Instacart