If fast food loves anything, it’s reinventing itself — for better or worse. But what people really love, sometimes, is good old consistency. Luckily, a few classics — the evergreens of fast food — have seen what works and followed the “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” rule. Decades later, they still look and taste just like they did on day one.
Here are nine fast-food items that have stayed the same.
In 1971, McDonald’s franchise owner Al Bernardinwanted a burger that felt more “adult-sized” than the chain’s regular patties, so he used a quarter pound of beef before cooking and kept the toppings classic: onions, pickles, ketchup, and mustard on a sesame seed bun. He aptly named it the Quarter Pounder at his Fremont, California restaurant, and it went nationwide in 1973 for 60 cents — 70 with cheese.
Aside from a slightly bigger patty in 2015 and a switch to fresh beef in 2018, the quarter pounder is still the same since it came out.
When Wendy’s opened its first restaurant in 1969, Dave Thomas wanted a dessert that felt like part of the meal, not an afterthought. He called Fred Kappus, an Ohio equipment guy who knew about a chocolate–vanilla malt sold at a Cleveland racetrack. They tweaked the flavor until it was just right — thick, cold, and smooth enough to sip through a straw if you were patient.
Back then, a Frosty cost 50 cents, and more than fifty years later it's still on the Wendy's menu, still in that same paper cup, and still one of the most ordered items Wendy's has ever sold. (Though they did just add new Frosty flavors.)
In 1967, Pittsburgh-area franchise owner Jim Delligatti created the Big Mac as a bigger option for customers who wanted more than a standard cheeseburger. Two all-beef patties, “special sauce,” lettuce, cheese, pickles, onions, and a three-part sesame seed bun made it stand out — and a year later it was on McDonald’s menus nationwide.
The build is still the same — middle bun and all — making it one of the most recognizable fast-food burgers in the world (though, understandably, the price of a Big Mac has gone up over the years).
The chicken sandwich that made Chick-fil-A a religion of its own showed up in 1964, when founder Truett Cathy figured out how to pressure-fry a boneless breast in minutes without drying it out. He slid it onto a toasted, buttered bun with two pickle chips — nothing else — and left it alone. Some sixty years later the chain is still serving it exactly that way, and nobody is complaining.
In 1963, In-N-Out added the Double-Double to the menu, and it’s been a West Coast staple ever since. The formula hasn't moved an inch — two burger patties, two slices of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and the chain's spread.
Order one today and it comes in the same paper wrap, built the same way, and with the same taste people have been lining up for since the '60s.
The Filet-O-Fish debuted on the menu in 1962, thanks toLou Groen, an Ohio franchise owner who was tired of watching Catholic customers leave on Fridays. His fried fish patty, steamed bun, tartar sauce, and half-slice of cheese crushed Ray Kroc’s pineapple-and-cheese “Hula Burger” in a sales showdown and stuck around for good. Six decades later, it’s still the same polarizing menu item, you eat only during Lent.
Burger King launched the Whopper in 1957 — exactly a decade before its rival the Big Mac — in Miami as its signature oversized burger. It included a flame-grilled beef patty, lettuce, tomato, pickles, ketchup, and mayo on a sesame seed bun. That combination has stayed the same for nearly seventy years, even as Burger King experimented with countless variations.
The original build is still on the menu and still the chain’s defining burger.
In 1940, Harland Sanders was running a roadside café in Kentucky when he perfected a way to cook chicken faster without losing flavor. Pressure frying did the trick, and his mix of 11 herbs and spices sealed the deal.
That blend went into a vault, the chicken went on the menu, and more than eighty years later it’s still made the same way.
White Castle's tiny square burger debuted in Wichita, Kansas, in 1921. It’s still steamed over onions, topped with a pickle, and served on a soft bun. The method, size, and taste are exactly what made it America’s first fast-food cult item.
Discover more fun fast-food trivia by signing up for our free newsletters.