16 Fast Food Items Overdue for a Comeback

When a fast food restaurant discontinues a menu item, it's not necessarily gone forever. The co-creator of the Adult Swim show "Rick and Morty" once got McDonald's to send him a bottle of its legendary (and long discontinued) Szechuan McNugget sauce. It begs the question: If enough diehard fans call for the return of a fast food item, will restaurants oblige? Here are some candidates for ressurection.

Related: The Best Fast Food Deals to Grab This Month

McDonald's created the limited-time Szechuan McNugget sauce to promote the 1998 animated film "Mulan." The sauce became something of a cult favorite. A bottle produced at the same time as the one sent to the "Rick and Morty" co-creator attracted a final bid of $15,350 at auction, and a limited run in 2017 ended with police called to quell angry crowds demanding the sauce. Somehow, the release of a live-action "Mulan" this year did not prompt a reboot of the McDonald's tie-in.

Related: How to Make 24 Fast Food Sauces with Copycat Recipes

McDonald's offered hot dogs in some U.S. markets during the 1990s, but the item failed to appeal to enough customers. Maybe it had something to do with what McDonald's cofounder Ray Kroc said in his autobiography: "There's no telling what's inside a hot dog's skin, and our standard of quality just wouldn't permit that kind of item." Tell that to the Americans who eat 7 billion hot dogs between Memorial Day and Labor Day alone, according to the National Hot Dog and Sausage Council, which says food carts and hipsters have made dogs trendy again.

Burger King hasn't figured out selling tiny burgers. It tried sliders (1987), then slightly bigger burgers called Burger Buddies (1990), and finally six-packs of mini burgers called "Burger Shots" (2009). None caught on, yet sliders are a huge deal at White Castle and other eateries.

Related: How to Make 26 Fast Food Favorites at Home

Along with the Filet-O-Fish, McDonald's introduced founder Ray Kroc's Hawaiian-inspired "Hula Burger" — grilled pineapple with cheese on top. It's no surprise the Filet-O-Fish won that popularity contest, but it'd be interesting to have a sample of what's probably fast food's only attempt at grilled fruit.

Related: 25 Weird and Wonderful McDonald's International Menu Favorites

Designed to compete with burger chains, the Bell Beefer was essentially a ground-beef taco on a bun: a Tex-Mex sloppy joe. It was popular, offered from the mid-1970s to the mid-1990s. A Facebook group named Taco Bell Please Bring back the Bell Beefer patiently awaits its return.

Filled with fresh vegetables and chunks of chicken, these were developed as a healthier alternative to the restaurant's signature cheeseburgers and milkshakes. Wendy's founder Dave Thomas called the wraps a "win-win situation," but a lack of demand eventually knocked them off the menu.

Related: We Tasted All 9 Wendy's Breakfast Sandwiches and This Is the Best

The company enlisted Jason Alexander (before "Seinfeld") to promote this sandwich, introduced in 1985 in a special two-section styrofoam container that kept hot and cold ingredients separate. Aside from the hassle of getting a deconstructed burger, the containers weren't exactly environmentally friendly, but fans appreciated the hefty serving of toppings such as lettuce and tomato. The McDLT had a sort-of return around 2011, called the Big and Tasty.

Burger King used to offer a bit of carnival nostalgia from 2009 to 2010 with its Funnel Cake Sticks, which were basically fried batter with powdered sugar and a sugary dipping sauce. This item wasn't exactly healthy, but it was a steal at only $1.50 a pack. The sticks were reintroduced for a brief time in 2019 for $1.99 per pack.

In 1979, Pizza Hut explained the complicated idea behind its Taco Pizza with a commercial that told viewers seven times that: "It's a pizza-looking, taco-tasting pizza." Pizza Hut's foray into Mexican cuisine didn't win over enough customers at the time, but now Mexican food is bigger than ever.

Related: The Best Mexican Restaurant in Every State

The name explains it all: Put salad in a cup, top it with dressing, and shake well. It's kind of a wonder that Shakers, introduced in 2000, aren't around today, with mason-jar salads all over food blogs and Instagram. Not to mention that this has to be the easiest way to prepare and eat a salad. The Facebook group "Bring back the McDonald's Salad Shaker" has 1,500 members and counting.

To compete against McDonald's Filet-O-Fish, Taco Bell developed a Seafood Salad that mixed whitefish, snow crab, and shrimp in a taco bowl. The chain even put out a snarky commercial trying to make the Filet-O-Fish look gross, but fish from Taco Bell was a hard sell in 1986. Now that fish tacos are everywhere, it might be time for Taco Bell to dive back into seafood.

Decadence. Gluttony. Cholesterol. The Double Down sandwich of 2010 consisted of bacon, cheese, and sauce between two patties of fried chicken. According to U.S. Department of Agriculture standards, one Double Down would have contained more than half of your daily allowance of sodium. But the customers lining up around the block for chicken sandwiches at Popeye's and Chick-fil-A probably wouldn't mind too much. 

Related: The Most Over-the-Top Fast Food of the Past 10 Years

The exact taste of McDonald's legendary deep-fried Onion Nuggets is lost to history. Well, not quite: It's reported that an archivist has preserved a sample of this cheap menu item from the 1970s in a climate-controlled room in Elk Grove, Illinois.

In 2003 Sonic decided to re-release Pickle-O's pickles, originally introduced in 1968. Sonic hoped the side dish would "delight billions of taste buds and millions of customers," but the chain was still a decade early. In the years since, fried pickles have become a staple nationwide, especially as bar food.

Ideal for the indecisive junk food eater, Frings were a simple dish of french fries and onion rings in the same package. Frings, introduced in 1979, have "gone the way of mood rings and shag carpeting," according to the Jack in the Box website — which is a little odd, since the Jack in the Box menu still includes french fries and onion rings that can be bought separately and combined.

Related: 21 Outrageous French Fries You Need to Try

The often-overlooked Rodeo Burger was found on Burger King's value menu, where it held its own against such staples as chicken nuggets and cheesy tots. It featured onion rings and barbecue sauce in place of cheese, and Serious Eats declared it an "unexpected jewel in Burger King's crown" — especially for the $1 price. Don't confuse the Rodeo Burger with its big sibling, the Rodeo King, which was a half-pound, 1,250-calorie monstrosity that threw bacon and mayo into the mix.

Related: We Tried 24 Fast-Food Sauces and These Are the Best (and Worst)