Front Exterior of Five Guys Burgers and Fries Restaurant in Nashville, Tennessee, Doors and Outdoor Seating Area

Yes, There Is a Five Guys Secret Menu. Here's What To Order During Your Next Visit

Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Folks, just about everything’s got a secret menu. Five Guys — the Washington, D.C.–born burger chain — is no exception. From grilled cheese customizations and hot dog variations, here are the Five Guys menu hacks that you need to know about.

Just remember: Be nice to your Five Guys employees. Give them a break when they’re understaffed or in the middle of a lunch rush. You already know the vibes.

burger bowl from Five GuysPhoto credit: Kristi M. / Yelp

Burger Bowl

To call an aluminum Five Guys takeout container a bowl is a stretch, but if you’re cutting carbs, you can get your burger patty and all the fixings without the bun.

The Artery Annihilator

  • Order a bacon cheeseburger.

  • Ask for a halved hot dog on top.

Well-Done Fries

This is pretty self explanatory. Order some of those peanut oil-laden French fries and ask for them well-done.

Patty Melt

Five Guys has Texas toast-esque bread on standby, so order your burger on that, rather than the traditional bun. Voilà, instant patty melt.

Sloppy Joe

While you cannot get an actual Sloppy Joe at Five Guys, there’s a decent way to simulate it. Allegedly, this tastes just like the real thing. A little bit of hot sauce works here, too.

  • Order a burger with no cheese.

  • Add grilled peppers and onions, ketchup, and barbecue sauce.

The Double-Double Dupe

While you can attempt to recreate In-N-Out’s burger at Five Guys, I’d say you needn’t bother. Nobody can do what In-N-Out does. Nobody.

  • Order a cheeseburger and add an extra slice of cheese.

  • Add lettuce, tomato, pickles, and grilled onions.

  • Mix ketchup, mayo, and relish together to create the special sauce.

  • Throw some melted cheese onto some fries along with that sauce to recreate Animal Fries.

five guys burgerPhoto credit: Tim M. / Yelp

Presidential Burger

When President Obama stopped at Five Guys, this is what he got. 

  • Order a cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, jalapeño peppers, and mustard.

Chicago Dog

Though Five Guys doesn’t have the crucial ingredients of sport peppers and celery salt, you can still hack your way to a Chicago-style hot dog.

  • Order a hot dog with tomato, relish, green peppers, pickles, mustard, and Cajun seasoning.

Double Grilled Cheeseburger

  • Start with any amount of beef patties you desire, and build your burger the way you like.

  • Then, instead of buns, ask for two grilled cheese sandwiches. 

  • Go for a run.

For more secret menu guides, please sign up for our free newsletters.

Cheapism in the News