Do the Lookalikes Taste Alike, Too?
Alex Wong/Getty Images News/Getty Images CC

Aldi Products That Taste Like Name Brands — and Some That Definitely Don't

View Slideshow
Do the Lookalikes Taste Alike, Too?
Alex Wong/Getty Images News/Getty Images CC

Do the Lookalikes Taste Alike, Too?

One of the first things newbies notice on their first trip to Aldi is how familiar some of its items appear. While most store brands imitate their name-brand rivals to some degree, Aldi has the practice down to a science. But beyond the copycat packaging, how do its products taste compared with the brands so many of us know and love? I set out to find out, and potentially save you some money along the way.

Methodology: Without knowing which product was which, I rated how closely matched each Aldi product and a corresponding name brand were on taste using a four-point scale (not very similar, somewhat similar, very similar, dead ringer). Once I rated the products for taste, I factored in the price difference to decide whether I would buy the Aldi product again.

Related: Over 50 Store-Brand Foods That Deliver Quality and Savings

Apple Juice
Cheapism

Apple Juice

Mott's can't be happy about how similar Aldi's Nature's Nectar Apple Juice parrots its product. They also can't be happy about how much cheaper it is: Aldi's juice was $1.25 versus $2.64 for the same size bottle of Mott's Apple Juice at Kroger. That's less than 2 cents an ounce for Aldi's brand and just over 4 cents an ounce for the name brand.

Apple Juice Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer
Cheapism

Apple Juice Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer

Appearance, taste, smell — nothing betrayed any difference between Aldi's apple juice and the familiar bottle of Mott's. In fact, I had to double-check that I didn't mistakenly test two glasses of the same juice.

Would I buy it again? I'd be silly not to.

Sliced Turkey
Cheapism

Sliced Turkey

While school's in, turkey sandwiches are a lunchbox staple, so any opportunity to save is a good one. Aldi charges $2.59 for a 9-ounce packet of its Lunch Mate Turkey breast, which comes in very similar packaging to Oscar Meyer's Deli Fresh Oven Roasted Turkey. The Oscar Meyer brand was $3.99 at Kroger. That's 28 cents an ounce for the Aldi brand, and 44 cents an ounce for the name brand.

Sliced Turkey Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer
Cheapism

Sliced Turkey Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer

I suspected these would be close going in, and I was right. It was impossible to detect any difference in taste between the two, though Oscar Meyer's turkey did have a "meatier," rougher texture, while Aldi's turkey was smoother and more lunch-meat like.

Would I buy it again? I'm all for cheaper turkey sandwiches, so definitely.

American Cheese
Cheapism

American Cheese

Kraft has made an empire from these yellow slices of nebulous foodstuff, and for our money, we don't want anything else on our grilled cheese sandwiches. Except, perhaps, Aldi's cheaper version. Sixteen of its Happy Farms Singles cost $1.65, while Kraft's iconic American Singles cost us $3.79. That's 10 cents a slice at Aldi, and a whopping 24 cents a slice for the name brand at Kroger.

American Cheese Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer
Cheapism

American Cheese Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer

Unless you're offended by the brighter yellow or slightly thicker cut of Aldi's cheese slices, they taste just as gloriously processed as Kraft's ubiquitous singles. And whatever differences there were completely evaporated on a sandwich.

Would we buy again? Definitely.

Blueberry Mini Muffins
Cheapism

Blueberry Mini Muffins

Another perennial kid favorite, these little pouches are unfortunately pricey, making them only an occasional lunch-box treat. But buying at Aldi may mean they start making an appearance more frequently: There, the Baker's Treat brand is $2.55 for five pouches versus $3.99 for Hostess at Kroger. That's 51 cents a pouch at Aldi, and 80 cents a pouch for the name brand.

Blueberry Mini Muffins Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer
Cheapism

Blueberry Mini Muffins Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer

These definitely looked, smelled, and tasted eerily similar. I had to double-check after tasting to make sure I was eating both brands, not just one.

Would we buy again? Definitely, much to my kids' delight.

Ketchup
Cheapism

Ketchup

That big red bottle doesn't have to come with a big price tag, especially during grilling season. A 38-ounce bottle of Aldi's Burman's brand ran us $1.35, or about 4 cents an ounce, while buying the same size bottle of Heinz at Kroger cost us $3.13, or about 8 cents an ounce.

Ketchup Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer
Cheapism

Ketchup Taste-Test Verdict: Dead Ringer

I didn't expect there to be much of a difference here, and I was right. Color, consistency and taste were very similar between both brands. Why do people buy name-brand ketchup, again?

Would we buy again? Absolutely.

Toaster Pastries
Cheapism

Toaster Pastries

A quick glance at a box of Millville Toaster Tarts might have you doing a double-take, as the similarity to Kellogg's Pop-Tarts is pretty uncanny. The price isn't similar, though: A 12-count box of Aldi's brand was $1.65, and the name brand was $2.99 at Kroger. That works out to just under 14 cents a pastry at Aldi, and 25 cents each for the name brand.

Toaster Pastries Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar
Cheapism

Toaster Pastries Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar

Interestingly, Aldi's Millville Toaster Tarts were a bit sweeter, with what seemed to be more cinnamon-sugar filling. In contrast, Kellogg's Pop-Tarts were a breadier — and I actually ended up preferring the Aldi brand.

Would I buy them again? Definitely, especially with the savings.

Toaster Waffles
Cheapism

Toaster Waffles

L'eggo my … Breakfast Best Homestyle Waffle? The slogan might not work well, but the unabashed packaging leaves no doubt that Aldi is gunning for Eggo with this frozen-food staple. Aldi's brand cost $1.35 for 10 waffles, or about 11 cents a waffle, while a 10-count package of Eggos at Kroger was $2.49, or 25 cents a waffle.

Toaster Waffles Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar
Cheapism

Toaster Waffles Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar

Aldi's Breakfast Best waffles look a little more raggedy around the edges than the uniform Eggos, but they taste almost exactly the same as their name-brand counterparts. Moreover, Aldi's brand had a lighter, crispier, more pleasant texture than the Eggos, which were chewier.

Would I buy them again? Yes — I actually preferred Aldi's waffles, and you can't beat the price.

Fruity Cereal
Cheapism

Fruity Cereal

Toucan Sam and Kellogg's Froot Loops have been cereal-aisle staples for as long as we can remember. It's unclear whether the avian mascot on Aldi's box of Millville Fruit Rounds has a name, but there's no mistaking what product he's supposed to evoke. At $1.45 for a 12-ounce box, Aldi's brand is about 12 cents an ounce, while we paid $3.54 for a 10.1-ounce box of Froot Loops at Kroger, or 35 cents an ounce.

Fruity Cereal Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar
Cheapism

Fruity Cereal Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar

Other than price, the biggest difference here is appearance: Aldi's Fruit Rounds aren't as brightly colored as the name brand. But the taste is almost dead on, especially in milk, though Kellogg's Froot Loops may be just a touch sweeter.

Would I buy it again? Definitely, especially knowing how fast my kids inhale cereal.

Swiss Rolls
Cheapism

Swiss Rolls

These indulgent, creamy snack cakes are a longtime snack-aisle staple, and there's no doubt that Little Debbie is the name to beat. But on price, there's no real contest: Aldi's Baker's Treat Swiss Rolls were just $1.49 cents for 12 cakes, or 12 cents a cake, while we paid $1.99 for 12 Little Debbie Swiss Rolls at Kroger, or about 17 cents a cake.

Swiss Rolls Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar
Cheapism

Swiss Rolls Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar

Aldi's Swiss Rolls aren't quite as pleasing to the eye or the hands — they're not as plump and the chocolate coating flakes off easier — but they taste very similar to Little Debbies, and might even be a little sweeter.

Would we buy again? Yes, and my wallet will thank me for it, if not my waistline.

Corn Chips
Cheapism

Corn Chips

It's hard to resist the siren song of that yellow bag when you need a vessel for your favorite dip. Of course, Aldi's siren song won't leave such a dent in your wallet. It cost 85 cents for a 9.25-ounce bag of Clancy's Corn Chips Big Dippers at Aldi, and $4.49 for an 15.5-ounce bag of Fritos Scoops at Kroger. That works out to 11 cents an ounce for Aldi's chips, and 29 cents an ounce for Fritos.

Corn Chips Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar
Cheapism

Corn Chips Taste-Test Verdict: Very Similar

Though I detected a little bit less crunch and salt while eating the Clancy's corn chips, the flavor profile was a very close match with Fritos.

Would we buy again? Yes, especially in bulk for parties when every cent counts.

Cheese Curls
Cheapism

Cheese Curls

They aren't Cheetos, but Aldi probably wouldn't mind if you blindly grabbed their orange bag of Clancy's Cheese Curls thinking they are. The price won't fool you, though. Aldi wants just $1.65 for an 8.5-ounce bag of its cheesy snack, while Kroger wants $2.99. That breaks down to 19 cents an ounce for the Aldi brand, and 35 cents an ounce for the name brand.

Cheese Curls Taste-Test Verdict: Somewhat Similar
Cheapism

Cheese Curls Taste-Test Verdict: Somewhat Similar

They look almost identical, but Aldi Clancy's Cheese Curls were slightly more bready and less cheesy than name-brand Cheetos.

Would I buy the Aldi brand again? In bulk for parties? Absolutely. For my own snack stash, I'm still going to grab Cheetos, preferably on sale.

Cheese Pizza Rolls
Cheapism

Cheese Pizza Rolls

Pizza rolls are always there for us when we need a tasty snack that will burn the skin from the roof of our mouths. But it seems sensible not to overpay for that experience, right? Aldi's Mama Cozzi's Cheese Pizza Snacks cost us $6.05 for 44.5 ounces, while we paid $6.99 for the same amount of Totino's Pizza Rolls at Kroger. That's 13 cents an ounce versus 16 cents an ounce, respectively.

Cheese Pizza Rolls Taste-Test Verdict: Somewhat Similar
Cheapism

Cheese Pizza Rolls Taste-Test Verdict: Somewhat Similar

Aldi's pizza rolls passed the real test with flying colors: They burned my mouth just as well as the name brand. Jokes aside, they had a much cheesier flavor profile, with a slightly puffier crust. The Totino's rolls had a more prominent sauce taste, and a chewier texture.

Would we buy again? Yes, though it really comes down to whether you are in it for the cheese (Aldi) or the sauce (Totino's).

Round Snack Crackers
Cheapism

Round Snack Crackers

Aldi isn't content to use the familiar red, blue and yellow of Nabisco Ritz Crackers box — in this case, there's an eerily similar name, too. But as with all things Aldi, the price is the real difference: $1.75 for 13.7 ounces of its Savoritz Original crackers versus $2.68 for the same size box of Ritz at Kroger. That's about 13 cents an ounce at Aldi, and 20 cents an ounce for the name brand.

Round Snack Crackers Taste-Test Verdict: Not Very Similar
Cheapism

Round Snack Crackers Taste-Test Verdict: Not Very Similar

These crackers look quite similar, but that's where the positives end for Aldi's brand. The Savoritz crackers were quicker to crumble and had a much breadier aftertaste, while the Ritz crackers were lighter, crispier, and more buttery. No contest here.

Would I buy them again? Nope — in this case, I'll happily pay more for the name brand.

Vegetarian 'Chicken' Patties
Cheapism

Vegetarian 'Chicken' Patties

We'll take a break from our regularly scheduled junk food to discuss a slightly better-for-you option. Aldi has expanded its healthier selections in recent years, and one such product is its Earth Grown Chickenless Patties. They cost $3.65 for four compared with $3.99 for four of MorningStar Farms Original Chick Veggie Patties at Kroger. That's 91 cents a patty at Aldi, and just under $1 at Kroger.

Vegetarian 'Chicken' Patties Taste-Test Verdict: Not Very Similar
Cheapism

Vegetarian 'Chicken' Patties Taste-Test Verdict: Not Very Similar

I have to give Aldi credit for courting vegetarians, but their Chickenless Patties were a resounding dud. While MorningStar's patty was pleasantly crispy, even after microwaving, with a surprisingly meaty flavor, Aldi's was confoundingly chewy and just … off. Tastes like chicken? Not so much.

Would we buy again? Not even if you paid me.

Diet Cola
Cheapism

Diet Cola

There's no mistaking who Aldi is imitating with its Diet Summit Cola. But there's a vast difference when it comes to price: $2.65 for a dozen cans at Aldi versus $5.49 for a 12 pack of Diet Coke at Kroger. That breaks down to 22 cents a can for Aldi's soda, and a whopping 46 cents a can for the name brand.

Diet Cola Taste-Test Verdict: Not Very Similar
Cheapism

Diet Cola Taste-Test Verdict: Not Very Similar

I could tell a difference just by smelling — Aldi's Diet Summit had a much more distinctive cola smell that Diet Coke lacked. That carried over in the taste, which was more robust than smooth, mild Diet Coke. There was also less carbonation with Aldi's brand.

Would I buy the Aldi brand again? I'm an unabashed Diet Coke devotee, so no. However, if you miss the taste of regular Coke and don't pucker at the sweetness every time you drink it, you might appreciate the bolder flavor of Diet Summit.