I am somebody who has eaten Peeps so infrequently that I honestly don’t know if I’ve ever had them at all. I mean, seriously, how many Peeps flavors are there? At this point, the lineup is evolving so much it seems infinite.
For 70 years, the classic yellow marshmallow bunnies and marshmallow chicks have been synonymous with Easter, and I don’t see the original Peeps flavors going anywhere any time soon.
But I bet you’ve tasted the classic marshmallow birds a million times. What you haven’t tasted, probably, are the freak show Peeps flavors. Are these a good idea? That’s a great question. I found out for you. Here are my thoughts on 12 marshmallow Peeps flavors, all of which you should probably avoid.
Prices and availability are subject to change.