Does Your State Prefer Real or Fake Christmas Trees?

Real vs. Fake tree by state

Halfpoint/istockphoto

Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.
Real vs. Fake tree by state
Halfpoint/istockphoto

Fir Real?

Christmas comes swiftly every year, and after a season of gift shopping, every dollar spent feels like a hefty weight. Christmas trees aren’t cheap, and those prices add up, too. 


Which states buy the real thing and which bust the fake ones out of storage each year? OnlineCasinos put together a little report about which states prefer real versus fake Christmas trees, along with a ton of piping hot holiday tree data. Here’s what they had to say. 

Christmas tree farm
arinahabich/istockphoto

Which States Prefer Real Christmas Trees?

The majority of our country prefers a real, living tree. Here are the states where real trees reign supreme: 

  • Alaska 
  • Colorado 
  • Connecticut 
  • Idaho 
  • Kentucky 
  • Maine 
  • Maryland 
  • Massachusetts 
  • Michigan 
  • Minnesota 
  • Missouri 
  • Montana 
  • Nebraska 
  • New Hampshire 
  • New Jersey 
  • New York 
  • North Dakota 
  • Ohio 
  • Oklahoma 
  • Oregon 
  • Pennsylvania 
  • Rhode Island 
  • South Carolina 
  • South Dakota 
  • Tennnessee 
  • Texas 
  • Utah 
  • Vermont 
  • Washington 
  • West Virginia 
  • Wisconsin 
  • Wyoming 
Christmas Tree Price Tag
u/high_gravity via Reddit.com

What Is the Average Cost of a Real Christmas Tree?

It’s no surprise that Christmas trees have gotten crazy expensive in the last 10 years. According to Finder, a Christmas tree in 2014 cost an average of about $40. It has since doubled: Today, trees cost around $80 on average.  

Boy holding a saw near cutting down Christmas tree
SerrNovik/istockphoto

What Are the Pros of Real Christmas Trees?

OnlineCasinos lists some pros and cons of both real and fake trees. Here’s what they had to say in favor of real trees. 

  • Real trees are biodegradable and renewable. 
  • When you buy a real tree, you are able to directly support local agriculture. 
  • Trees are, of course, good for the planet, and help to absorb carbon dioxide. 
Christmas tree in the back of a pick up truck
Pete Van Vleet/istockphoto

What Are the Cons of Real Christmas Trees?

Real trees are an undeniable hassle. You’ll need to find a way to transport it home, and getting rid of it is no picnic if you’re trying to do it responsibly.  

Artificial pine tree for Christmas decoration
RHL Acil Banjar/istockphoto

Which States Prefer Fake Christmas Trees?

Only 18 states prefer fake trees. Here are the ones that are setting up Christmas with a lot less hassle than the rest of the country: 

  • Alabama 
  • Arizona 
  • Arkansas 
  • California 
  • Delaware 
  • Florida 
  • Georgia 
  • Hawaii 
  • Illinois 
  • Indiana 
  • Iowa 
  • Kansas 
  • Louisiana 
  • Mississippi 
  • Nevada 
  • New Mexico 
  • North Carolina 
  • Virginia 
Latin mature woman decorating a Christmas tree. Low angle view, copy space
Carolina Jaramillo/istockphoto

What Are the Pros of Fake Christmas Trees?

Here are some of the pros of an artificial tree: 

  • This is a one-time purchase, and you’ll use it for many years. 
  • Fake trees are extremely low-maintenance, which means no watering. 
  • They always look healthy.  
Christmas tree disaster
RonTech2000 / istockphoto

What Are the Cons of Fake Christmas Trees?

Unfortunately, they’re not great for the environment since they aren't made of renewable materials and use up lots of electricity. 

Sale of many artificial Christmas trees in green, purple and white at a decor store. The sale of a variety of artificial Christmas trees
Pridannikov/istockphoto

What Is the Average Cost of a Fake Christmas Tree?

According to NBC, the average Christmas tree costs about $100. If that’s the case, they are no longer that much pricier than the real thing, and they come with multiple years of use. 

Cheerful couple shop for the perfect Christmas tree
SDI Productions/istockphoto

How To Choose the Perfect Tree

OnlineCasinos suggests the following if you’re looking to pick out the perfect tree, real or fake. 

  • Make sure your tree is right for the space it’s going in. 
  • Be sure you’re ready for the maintenance required for either type of tree. 
  • If you do buy a real tree, aim for local farmers rather than places like Home Depot. 
  • Take care of your tree by watering it to extend its life. 

For more smart holiday news, please sign up for our free newsletters.