How the Cookie Crumbles
Girl Scout cookies hold a nostalgic place in my heart — I was the top cookie seller in my troop, after all. But it's been a while since I've eaten many of the cookies (and some I have never tried at all), so it was past time to revisit them. I got my hands on every Girl Scout cookie flavor I could, which, in my area, means all the ABC Baker varieties, like Caramel deLites and Lemonades as opposed to Somoas and Lemon-Ups. One flavor I couldn't get my hands on, though: Raspberry Rally. The limited edition cookie was new for 2023, and sold out within hours of going on sale. I wasn't about to buy a box on the black market (and my inquiries to the Girl Scouts went unanswered), so I ranked the remaining nine flavors offered in my area based on criteria like taste, texture, and dunkability.
Related: How To Buy Girl Scout Cookies Online