The Creepiest Things For Sale Online This Week (5/17/23)

Interior, 17 Route 13A, Prattsville, NY 12468

CCND MLS/Zillow

Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.
Interior, 17 Route 13A, Prattsville, NY 12468
CCND MLS/Zillow

We like finding a deal as much as anyone, but sometimes a deal may mean an actual deal with the devil? There are some truly terrifying “used” things you can buy online, and it turns out many of them come with their very own spirit. Some people live (die?) for this type of stuff based on the number of listings out there, but we pray our soul wasn’t snatched just writing this story.

Haunted Clown Doll
Cheapism/Ebay

Haunted Clown Doll

The owner says this clown doll told them subliminally that its name is Jovial Jo. The owner discovered “Jo” was a popular clown who performed all over the country for decades before being murdered. That’s a NOPE.

Cursed Vintage Doll
Cheapism/Ebay

Cursed Vintage Doll

The lister claims they constantly heard banging coming from closets in the spaces near where the doll was left hanging in the attic. They also heard hissing in the darkness when the doll was discovered. Goose bumps literally thinking about it.

Raggedy Andy Doll
Cheapism/Ebay

Raggedy Andy Doll

The doll supposedly is possessed by the spirit of a friendly man who died in his 70s and just wants to be with a family again. It won’t be our family, sorry not sorry.

Melissa and Doug Doll
Cheapism/Ebay

Melissa and Doug Doll

When you realize your daughter owns the exact. Same. Doll. (Guess who is sleeping with one eye open tonight.)

Haunted Mirror and Hair Brush
Cheapism/Ebay

Haunted Mirror and Hair Brush

After this lister brought the set home from an estate sale, they saw a small woman in their home and smelled flowers. Thanks, but we’ll just buy a hair brush from Walmart.

Haunted Human Ash
Cheapism/istockphoto

Haunted Human Ash

Whether this is fake or not, it's a hard, hard pass. Good luck with that one, seller.

Haunted Dolls
Cheapism/istockphoto

Haunted Dolls

At this point, we’ve seen enough spooky dolls for sale to last us a lifetime (and our after life as well.)

The Withered Rose Doll
Cheapism/Ebay

The Withered Rose Doll

This doll was so damn frightening we couldn’t leave it out, solely so you could be as absolutely terrified as we are. The doll supposedly embodies the spirit of a very temperamental woman named Rose who was not to be messed with.

17 Route 13A, Prattsville, NY 12468
Cheapism/CCND MLS/Zillow

Historic Hotel

It’s not all just creepy dolls for sale online — you can also buy a creepy home! You can almost see Jack Nicholson going insane here (also that ride-on horse toy in a photo is not doing the listing any favors.)

5348 Hollenbeck Rd, Lockport, NY 14094
Cheapism/WNYREIS MLS/Zillow

Home Built in 1852

Buyers are advised to enter the building at their own risk and wear protective equipment. But hey! If you’re looking for a quiet space with no neighbors, this listing says this may be for you! In other words, no one can hear you if you scream.