Best All-Season Tires

By   

View as:

several tires
Photo credit: baranq/shutterstock

KEEP ON ROLLING

Odds are, your vehicle rides on all-season tires. They're the most common type of tire available, designed for everyday driving in a variety of weather conditions, from dry, to wet, to even light snow. Experts say choosing the best all-season tire depends on the kind of automobile you own, how aggressively you drive, and the climate where you live. Since all-season tires are not all created equally (even tires from the same maker), and some cheap tires priced only a little below the best choices really do fall short when it comes to traction, handling, riding comfort, and longevity, Cheapism.com consulted professional tire tests and owner reviews to identify top-rated all-season tires that deliver performance and value for daily commuters on a budget. We also recommend specialty all-season tires designed for sports cars, hybrids, and luxury sedans that deliver good to great performance and safety, as well as durability over the long haul. If you drive a four-wheel-drive or full-size pickup or SUV, see our review of truck and off-road tires for more recommendations. Our review of snow tires provides picks for drivers in regions that are prone to cold weather, snow, and ice.

*Prices and availability are subject to change. Starting prices are generally for smallest tire sizes for each line.

General Tire Altimax RT43
Photo credit: Courtesy of carid.com

GENERAL TIRE ALTIMAX RT43

Best Value All-Season Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $64 | Buy them from Tire Rack

Pros:
- Good performance under all driving conditions.
- Better-than-average snow traction in tests.
- Strong performance in comparative Tire Rack testing; among the top in its category in other independent tests.

Cons:
- Driver reviews, while positive, are a bit more mixed than with other models.
- Ride is a little noisy, some drivers complain.
- Wet braking could be better, but about typical for an all-season.

Takeaway: You can find all-season tires that might be longer wearing, but according to professional tests and owner reviews you'll still get your money's worth out of these General Altimax tires. The ride is comfortable, though a touch noisy at times, and performance is excellent when compared to other options in this price range; in Tire Rack testing they handled better than more expensive models. Snow traction — an issue with most all-season tires — is also better than the norm. Experts like this tire a lot, with some saying the General Altimax RT3 definitely gives our top-runner, the Michelin Defender T+H, a run for its money, especially since a full set comes in at a fraction of the cost. Treadwear is warrantied to 75,000 miles, but several owners say they got only about 50,000 to 60,000 miles before the tires reached their limit. Still, most insist that they're very satisfied with the ride and handling of these all-seasons.

Michelin Defender T+H
Photo credit: Courtesy of michelinman.com

MICHELIN DEFENDER T+H

Best All-Season Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $96 | Buy them from Tire Rack

Pros:
- Long treadwear warranty and even better tread life, according to independent tests.
- A top all-season tire recommendation by Consumer Reports.
- Responsive handling.
- Relatively low road noise.
- Named best in category by Tire Rack customers.

Cons:
- Doesn't test as well as some other all-season tires on wet roads.
- Less comfortable ride than some tires.
- Only so-so fuel economy.

Takeaway: It's not the cheapest all-season tire you can buy, but the Michelin Defender T+H is one of the best for the money, according to both consumer product experts and tire professionals. Its 80,000-mile treadwear warranty is one of the longest around, and long-term road tests suggest that these tires can go even longer before needing to be replaced. While some experts have some quibbles with this Michelin's performance when braking on wet roads, owner comments don't indicate that this is an issue in real-world driving. It's an exceptionally quiet tire and provides a ride that has been described as "athletic" by Tire Rack testers, but at the expense of some ride comfort compared to other tires in its class.

Continental PureContact LS
Photo credit: Courtesy of sullivantire.com

CONTINENTAL PURECONTACT LS

Best Grand Touring Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $112 | Buy them from Tire Rack

Pros:
- Outstanding tread life, according to owners.
- Very good handling in wintry conditions.
- Low road noise.

Cons:
- Won't satisfy drivers looking for a true performance tire.
- Pricier than standard all-season tires.

Takeaway: A grand touring tire splits the difference between a standard touring tire and a performance tire, and reviewers say these Continental PureContact LS grand touring all-season tires are an excellent option for those who want an upgraded driving experience. This tire carries a V speed rating, meaning it can travel as fast as 149 mph, and professional testers generally find no shortcomings in key criteria under different driving conditions. The PureContact LS performs above average (for an all-season) in ice or snow, and durability is top-notch, too — it carries a 75,000-mile treadwear warranty but was able to go 90,0000 miles before needing replacement in one long-term test. Because this is a newer model, owner reviews are fairly limited, but what feedback exists is mostly good, and the model it replaces earned positive marks from both experts and owners. While diehard driving enthusiasts may not get the thrill that a true performance tire delivers, less aggressive daily drivers should be quite pleased with this luxury tire's capabilities. Continental tires also come with upgraded service perks, like 3 years of complimentary flat-tire roadside assistance and replacements should tires be damaged on the road within the first 12 months.

BFGoodrich g-Force COMP-2 A/S
Photo credit: Courtesy of tirebuyer.com

BFGOODRICH G-FORCE COMP-2 A/S

Best Value All-Season Ultra-High Performance Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $103 | Buy them from Tire Rack

Pros:
- Outstanding handling under all road conditions, according to professional testers.
- One of the better performers in this class on snow and ice.
- Strong reviews from experts and owners alike.

Cons:
- Not great for fuel economy.
- More road noise than some other tires in this category.

Takeaway: If you're looking for an ultra-high performance all-season tire and the price tag on our top performance tire, the Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+, is a little hard to swallow, experts and drivers say you won't sacrifice too much by opting instead for the BFGoodrich g-Force COMP-2 A/S. Like other performance tires, the Goodrich carries a W (168 mph) or Y (186 mph) speed rating depending on size, and handling is strong and controlled under all weather conditions, including wet and winter driving. The 45,000-mile treadwear warranty is typical for this class, and reviews indicate it should easily meet or even beat that mark. Testers at Tire Rack say "some noticeable tread growl is always present," but, as long as you don't mind road noise that's a little louder than the norm, the bang that's offered for the buck — and the balance of responsiveness and grip — is pretty impressive.

Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+
Photo credit: Courtesy of tirebuyer.com

MICHELIN PILOT SPORT A/S 3+

Best Ultra-High Performance All-Season Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $133 | Buy them from Tire Rack

Pros:
- Solid traction, handling, and braking under all conditions.
- Strong winter performance.
- Best in its class in Tire Rack track tests.
- Good tread life.
- Exceptionally positive owner reviews.

Cons:
- Ride is too firm for some drivers.
- Most costly tire we recommend.
- Fuel efficiency is not the best.

Takeaway: The Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+ is the most expensive tire we reviewed, but for the price it delivers just about everything a performance-oriented driver demands, reviewers say —including W and Y speed ratings in its different sizes. In professional closed-track tests, handling and braking is at the top of the charts on dry pavement and nearly as good in wet and wintry conditions. And this tire should have no issues meeting or even exceeding its 45,000-mile tread life warranty, according to long-term tests. Drivers adore the Pilot Sport A/S 3+, rating it tops in Tire Rack's large consumer survey, with professional testers there saying it "sets the bar for performance from an all-season tire." In fact, experts across the board struggle to find anything bad to say to balance out the accolades bestowed upon these Michelin tires.

Atlas Force HP
Photo credit: Courtesy of amazon.com

ATLAS FORCE HP

Best Cheap Performance All-Season Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $55 | Buy them from Simple Tire

Pros:
- Very low price, especially for a performance tire.
- Good handling in all weather conditions.
- Designed for low rolling resistance and better gas mileage.

Cons:
- Noise and ride comfort is middling.
- Limited driver feedback.

Takeaway: Professional reviewers say the Atlas Force HP performs well for a tire in this speed class, especially considering its low price. These are high performance tires with a V speed rating, meaning they have a top limit of 149 mph and are designed for aggressive driving. The tires are responsive under wet and dry conditions, slightly less so in wintry weather but still decent. The 40,000-mile treadwear warranty is standard for performance all-season tires, and long-term road testing indicates that these Atlas tires should exceed that. The biggest drawback is that owner reviews for this tire are relatively few, as is the case with many cheap all-season tires, but expert assessments suggest most users would not be disappointed with this deal.

Bridgestone DriveGuard
Photo credit: Courtesy of bridgestonetire.com

BRIDGESTONE DRIVEGUARD

Bonus: All-Season Run-Flat Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $118 | Buy them from Tire Rack

Pros:
- Can drive up to 50 miles (at 50 mph) after a flat.
- Very good traction on dry and wet roads.
- Comparatively little road noise.
- Additional 1-year warranty for damage due to road hazards.

Cons:
- So-so durability.
- Relatively poor handling on snow and ice.

Takeaway: Run flats (tires that can continue to be used for a limited number of miles after a puncture or loss of air pressure) don't generally get terrific reviews from experts or owners, but if you have a car that lacks a spare, or you want the added convenience and safety of not having to fix a flat while on the road, Bridgestone DriveGuards are one of the better options, reviewers say; in fact, the company developed the first full line of replacement run-flat tires. On the plus side, this tire is a very good performer on dry and wet roads, and it delivers an exceptionally quiet ride. Testing found it to be good on snow and ice, as well, although Tire Rack users rate its performance in winter weather conditions only "fair." The treadwear warranty isn't particularly long, just 60,000 miles — and testing indicates that these tires might struggle to meet even that threshold — but coverage is still fairly generous considering that some run-flat tires offer no treadwear warranty at all. These Bridgestone tires carry H, W or V speed ratings, so they're compatible with a wide range of vehicles.

Continental ExtremeContact Sport
Photo credit: Courtesy of continentaltire.com

CONTINENTAL EXTREMECONTACT SPORT

Bonus: Summer Tires
Est. Price: Starting around $95 | Buy them from Tire Rack

Pros:
- Good performance on wet roads.
- Responsive and reliable handling at high speeds, according to road testers at Car and Driver.
- Covered by Continental's "Total Confidence Plan," which includes 3 years complimentary flat-tire roadside assistance and replacements for damage within the first 12 months.

Cons:
- Not suitable for driving in wintry conditions.
- Harsher ride than other tires, according to Tire Rack testing.
- Relatively short treadwear warranty.

Takeaway: Designed for sports cars and luxury performance sedans, the Continental ExtremeContact Sport carries W and Y speed ratings, meaning they can reach top speeds of 186 mph. Testing verifies that handling is exceptional on wet and dry surfaces, and driver reviews put the ExtremeContact Sport in the top tier of summer performance tires. The treadwear warranty is comparatively short at 30,000 miles, but long-term road testing by MotoIQ found that tread life is notably improved from the Continental ExtremeContact DW which it replaces. A small step below the very best summer tires, such as the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S (starting around $181; Buy them at Tire Rack), but a big step below them in price, these Continental tires are a great value buy for driving enthusiasts. Just keep in mind, these are three-season tires, not all-season, so they are not intended to be driven on snow and ice. Unless you live in warmer climes, you'll have to swap them out for snow tires during the winter months.

Cheapism.com participates in affiliate marketing programs, which means we may earn a commission if you choose to purchase a product through a link on our site. This helps support our work and does not influence editorial content.