I Tried 9 Kinds of Buttermilk Pancake Mix and This Was the Winner

various pancake mixes

Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.
various pancake mixes
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

Brunch Bests

I'm not sure how we all agreed that it's OK to eat stacks of fried cake for breakfast, but I'm not here to argue about it. And on a nice, sunny weekend morning, there's no better way to start the day. Maybe even on a weekday, if you've got the time.


But you've got options at the grocery store when it comes to pancake mix, so what should you choose? Which box is going to yield you the best pancake? I tried nine different brands and found out.


Prices and availability are subject to change.

Related: I Tried 7 Frozen Breakfast Sandwiches, But None of Them Put Starbucks to Shame

chocolate chip pancakes
chocolate chip pancakes by Joy (CC BY)

Methodology

After running my tiny apartment kitchen like a diner and frying up pancake after pancake, I was able to taste them all hot off the griddle, er, frying pan.


The truth is, most of these are very similar. We're talking about tiny differences, some of which may even be based in the slightest change in ingredient ratio. The point is, there's not really a clear way to say definitively that some of these are better than the others. 


So, here's what we're gonna do. In my opinion, the perfect pancake is light, fluffy, and shining with a balanced level of sweetness. That's the scale: Light, fluffy, and sweet. The top pancake hits those marks the most, and the bottom hits those marks the least. 


Related: Best Frozen Waffles: We Tried 8 — These Are the Best

Birch Benders Micro-Pancakery Organic Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

Best: Birch Benders Micro-Pancakery Organic Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix

$3.97 from Walmart

Shop Now


Light and Fluffy: 4/5

Sweetness: 4/5


I loved these, and for an egg-less batter, I'm shocked how rich and sweet they tasted. Nothing like a micro-pancakery, eh?

Krusteaz Buttermilk Complete Pancake Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism
King Arthur Baking Company Buttermilk Pancake Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism
Pioneer Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

4. Pioneer Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix

$4.18 from Walmart

Shop Now


Light and Fluffy: 3/5

Sweetness: 4/5


The packaging might not lead you to believe what big flavors await you inside, but they're there. The recipe calls for butter in addition to egg, and in my experience, there's nothing but happiness ahead when butter is involved. 


Related: 45 Best Homemade Pancake Recipes

Maple Grove Farms Buttermilk and Honey Pancake & Waffle Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

5. Maple Grove Farms Buttermilk and Honey Pancake & Waffle Mix

$12.99 from Walmart

Shop Now


Light and Fluffy: 3/5

Sweetness: 3/5


For the only box with the word "honey" printed on it, I expected better sweetness. The flavor is solid, but I wish it was sweeter, especially when I've got honey on the brain.

Trader Joe's Buttermilk Pancake & Baking Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

6. Trader Joe's Buttermilk Pancake & Baking Mix

Available in-store at Trader Joe's


Light and Fluffy: 2/5

Sweetness: 3/5


There's nothing inherently wrong with the Trader Joe's pancake mix. There's nothing inherently... anything. It's slightly and boring, but that's the worst I can say. 

Bob's Red Mill Whole Grain Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

7. Bob's Red Mill Whole Grain Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix

$10.85 from Walmart

Shop Now


Light and Fluffy: 2/5

Sweetness: 3/5


As far as whole grain pancakes go, these are amongst the best I've tasted. The hearty wheat flavor throughout is actually nice and helps to build a big flavor profile. Covered in syrup, this is the whole package, but for me, floury buttermilk flavors will always triumph over whole grain.

Hungry Jack Complete Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

8. Hungry Jack Complete Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix

$2.77 from Walmart

Shop Now


Light and Fluffy: 4/5

Sweetness: 1/5


Weirdly enough, this fluffed up in a beautifully pillowy way and had solid texture, but the flat flavor inside holds it back from any greatness. I'd buy it again in a pinch.

Bisquick Shake 'n Pour Buttermilk Pancake Mix
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

9. Bisquick Shake 'n Pour Buttermilk Pancake Mix

$3.76 from Walmart

Shop Now


Light and Fluffy: 1/5

Sweetness: 1/5


This review isn't all bad. The shaker bottle system at play here is ingenious. You just add water, shake it up inside the bottle, and pour into your pan. Unfortunately Bisquick lacks any sort of flavor whatsoever, and this is the type of pancake that makes you think to yourself, "Do I even like pancakes?"